In response to the white privilege column
By Kenzie Schmitt, Warner College of Natural Resources student
____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
Ad
It was more difficult for me to finish reading the article On the topic of ‘White Privilege’ than I would like to admit. The ignorance displayed was quite impressive, considering the resources for education on social issues that are available on this campus.
When writing an article, one of the most important things to do is to research the issue. This article showed the author did research on many issues, including Irish history and European immigration. However, the author neglected to do research on the main point they were trying to discuss, which is white privilege. This article was posted ‘Opinion’, as if this is an issue without real facts to discuss. While people can have their own opinions, they cannot have their own facts, and this article appeared to ignore the facts about privilege and living without it in America.
The idea of white privilege is not about what your family has gone through, or about the struggles of all humans in the world. White privilege is about the systematic oppression of non-white folks. In America, this stems in part from things like slavery, where white men declared they were better than people of color and asserted their dominance over them in one of the most dehumanizing ways possible. After slavery was abolished, the white people in power did not want to give up their power, and used the constitution to prohibit non-white, non-males from voting, used laws that allow stop-and-frisks that disproportionately affect non-white Americans, and used a justice system that is skewed to allow non-white low level drug offenders to be incarcerated at much higher rates than white people accused of the same crimes. Through all the struggles of people of color through the years and all the incredible progress they have made, we are not in a post-racial society. People of color are incarcerated at a rate of nearly 6 times the rate of white people. This is a translation from putting people of color in chains to putting them behind bars. Both have been and continue to be oppressive and contribute to the difference in experience that people of color live versus white people.
I am a white female. I was not raised to think that race was still an issue in America. Learning that this was simply not true was a hard lesson. Coming to terms with having white privilege was harder. I felt guilty and I wanted to push that feeling away from me as much as I could. I would tell myself that my life was hard too, in its own way. I would deny that there were real issues. I could say life for everyone, even white people, was hard. But in truth, life is not nearly as hard for me as a white person with all my struggles as it is for a person of color with all their struggles to live with the daily oppression that people of color experience.
White privilege is about seeing that you have experienced your life differently because of all the history and all the oppression still active in our society. White privilege is not something someone can ever rid themselves of, and I will continue to experience my life as a white person. When I need to ‘check my privilege,’ it is because I am not seeing the struggles of others who do not have my privilege, and it would benefit me to see the situation from another perspective. Perhaps the phrase ‘check your privilege’ is not the most inviting way to say it, but it has the intent of asking a person to take a step back and reassess their view for power-maintaining biases.
There is so much more to say on the issue of privilege, but I think it best for readers to explore the ideas and facts on their own, and take it upon themselves to learn what they can about social justice in America. CSU has resources for this, including the Black/African American Culture Center, the Native American Cultural Center, the Asian Pacific American Cultural Center, the El Centro, the Women and Gender Advocacy Center, the GLBT Resource Center, and more.
I now speak directly to you, Megan Burnett. I understand that the feeling of having privilege is unpleasant. But it is not acceptable to deny the pains of others in order to feel better about yourself. Race is still a real issue in America. The first thing you can do to begin to accept the privilege you have is to learn about it. Learn about the real issues of marginalized groups in race, ethnicity, gender, sexual orientation, and so many others who are not given space to use their voices the same way you are. Then it is appropriate to take action by writing articles about the real issues our society faces. This is how we can make progress as a society.
Roth Jackson • Nov 5, 2015 at 9:02 pm
great response Kenzie. i’d like to read more from you on this rag of a school paper.
Shelby • Oct 19, 2015 at 2:41 pm
THANK YOU, that other article drove me bonkers.
elybrown • Oct 13, 2015 at 10:29 am
Kenzie, interesting take on the white privledge arguement. To me, I find it offensive when young people today continue to parade racisim around like it is some sort of original sin that we must attone for. It is our responsability as educated adults to hold our fellow person accountable for their success or lack ther of. The idea that pursuing social justice as an ends to a means is antithetical to the american experience. Absolutly no where in the United States Constitution does it say that equality of outcome is a rite. If it is so bad here to live in this racist country, please enlighten us as to why so many people (by and large non-white) are willing to die to come here and make a life. I hope I didn’t hurt any bodies feelings with my little rant.
Simon • Oct 11, 2015 at 2:03 pm
Phenomenal response, I too had trouble finishing the “Topic of White Privilege” article. To say or imply ethnicity and heritage have nothing to do with ones success is painfully ignorant.
White privilege is extremely real and denying it’s existence is laughable.
Hamidah Glasgow • Oct 11, 2015 at 11:16 am
Thank you for the thoughtful and well written letter. White privilege is misunderstood and highly problematic. Thank you for taking a stand and informing those unaware of its destructive powers.
Shanon Cooper • Oct 10, 2015 at 5:12 pm
ok just read the article by Megan Burnett and commented :
Shanon Cooper
•
2 minutes ago
hmmm… “complicated” — but incorrect for a bunch of white people
to sit around and decide what is or is not considered “Racism”…
Ahora sigueme si entiende mi espanol acere — porque en ingles te podia
atropellar y no es mi intencion. mi hijo, por parte de su papa, es
americano nativo (apache) y mexicano. desgraciadamente era victima de
discriminacion racial en su salon de 4to grado, y la explicacion que le
dieron sus maestras de la situacion era de que esta “complicada” …..
(era el unico estudiante de su salon cuya fotografia era omitida de el
de un muro dedicado al “Western Expansion”, osea “Pioneers”. Aparte
tuvo que aguantar los comentarios de algunos de sus companeros de clase
— for example that shouldn’t he be extinct by now, or that “Indians ate
buffalo poop”, entre otras cosas que se hace uno pensar que las cosas
no van muy bien). We are talking about 4th graders in Poudre School
District. Entonces we filed a discrimination complaint with the US
Department of Education Office of Civil Rights, among other
documentation, but it has been a stressful process. Lo importante es
que estamos platicando sobre estos asuntos como sociedad porque el
silencio se mata. Addressing these issues collectively and recognizing
the “complexity” of our society is an important step in moving forward
as a community and as a nation. Talking about leveling the playing
field of privilege is something that will need to be addressed as ours
and coming generations define the future.
Shanon Cooper • Oct 10, 2015 at 4:41 pm
Very articulate. Have not read the article that you responded to but this stands on its own.
Patrick Donovan • Oct 9, 2015 at 9:15 pm
Thank you, Kenzie! hopefully this serves as a dose of reality for Megan Burnett and the Collegian’s editorial staff
Adrian Felix • Oct 9, 2015 at 4:58 pm
And on this day, October 9th of 2015, the tea was poured.
Thank you Kenzie, for this thoughtful and well written letter. Thank you for letting me know that I have allies and friends in this community at CSU.