The Mountain West’s legal battle with the Pac-12 and the five schools set to leave it isn’t slowing down.
As the 2025-26 athletic season approaches, Boise State, Colorado State and Utah State — three of the schools bound for the Pac-12 in 2026 — filed an updated lawsuit against the conference and Commissioner Gloria Nevarez Aug. 7. The schools accused the MW of depriving them of membership rights, withholding tens of millions of dollars and misleading them about a plan to move Grand Canyon’s start date up a year. Fresno State and San Diego State, the other two departing members, are not part of the suit due to state restrictions.
At the core of the case is money the schools claim they’ve already earned.
That includes BSU’s College Football Playoff payout from 2024, unpaid travel reimbursements and NCAA distributions meant for academic support, athlete welfare programs and financial aid. The MW bylaws state the league can hold back distributions once a school gives its exit notice, applying those funds toward whatever exit fee remains.
The fees themselves are another fight.
The fees for leaving the conference could range from $19 million to $38 million, which is well above the league’s historical average. Mediation last month didn’t work. The Mountain West offered to cut the number to $18 million, but the departing schools originally expected $8 million to $12 million; neither side moved much from there.
The lawsuit also takes aim at GCU’s accelerated entry, announced after the three schools resigned in May and lost their voting rights. Plaintiffs said Nevarez denied any change before that and argued the decision could disrupt scheduling, tournament seeding and NCAA bid chances. They also claim they haven’t seen the membership agreement or how it might affect revenue sharing.
League officials said they acted within their rights and pointed to examples in other conferences. When Texas and Oklahoma left the Big 12, they lost board seats and new members came in early. Nevarez has said the MW will cover any documented extra travel and scheduling costs from GCU’s addition. The Antelopes will also pay an entry fee and annual dues and forfeit their first-year distribution.
The conference has argued the departing schools helped create the exit fee rules and even tried to enforce them against San Diego State two years ago. In a separate case, the Mountain West is seeking $55 million in “poaching fees” from the Pac-12 for adding its departing members.
Both sides are digging in.
Lowering the exit fee could ease the financial hit for the schools heading to the Pac-12, where future revenue remains uncertain. For the MW, the stakes includes upholding its bylaws and securing payouts it believes it’s owed in a realignment fight that isn’t over.
Reach Michael Hovey at sports@collegian.com or on Twitter @michaelfhovey.